skip navigation

Officially Speaking: A new evaluation

11/06/2018, 10:45am CST
By Mark Lichtenfeld

Remember, this is amateur hockey. Keep it all in perspective.

Let’s Play Hockey photo by Mike Thill

Probably the worst aspect of amateur hockey officiating is the overall improper perspective that players, coaches and parents have toward the non-professional game. I mean, from house, travel, low-level JV and even beer league, all the buzz is about deficient officiating and the necessities for evaluations of zebras.

Now, OS is all about calling every game to the best of an official’s ability at all times. Unfortunately, the noun, game, is subject to interpretation. 

If you recall last week’s column, OS discussed a AAA PeeWee game, which was basically a smaller version of an NHL game without checking. That was a game.

But the truth is that a majority of assignments handled by the veteran Level 3 cannot even be put in the same classification as an AAA game, notwithstanding the opinions of parents and butcher league wives. And because the level of play in these games is what it is, officiating becomes most difficult, and evaluations of referees in these types of contests are incredibly subjective and overwhelmingly unproductive.

But if the hockey community is going to demand such evaluations, then OS respectfully proffers the following game evaluation sheet for both the improvement of all participants and protection of the venerable Level 3 official:

Level 3 Official Team Evaluation and Game Summary
Teams on Ice Promptly at Game Time: Y  N

Players Have Matching Uniforms and Visible Numbers: Y  N

Players’ Gloves Conform to Minimal Hygiene Code: Y  N

Centers’ Sticks in Proper Location for All Faceoffs: Y  N

Coaches Refrain From Swearing and Other Anti-Social Behavior: Y  N

Players Display Hustle at All Times: Y  N

Defensemen Play Body Instead of Watching Puck: Y  N

All Checking Occurs With Trunk of Body and Hands Down: Y  N

Coaches Send Captain to Referee in Lieu of Hollering From Bench: Y  N

Players Properly Support Puck Away From the Play: Y  N

Players Demonstrate Crisp Passing: Y  N

Parents Show Class to All Participants, Including Officials: Y  N

Pretty simple, right? See, evaluations can work both ways. And just looking at the aforementioned classifications, a substantial percentage of games OS has seen have failed a majority of the above items, and 99 percent of OS’s several thousand beer league games over the past 28 years have flunked every single applicable classification.

There you have it. Make photocopies. Pass this evaluation around to parents and adult league spouses in the stands and score your respective teams.

Then remember, this is amateur hockey. Keep it all in perspective.


Questions and comments can be sent to, via Twitter @OSpeaking or through the Let’s Play Hockey Facebook page.

Top Stories

  • Team Minnesota

  • 04/19/2019, 11:00am CDT , By Let's Play Hockey
  • Our picks for Minnesota's top pro, college and junior hockey players during the 2018-19 season
  • Read More

Tag(s): State Of Hockey  News  Officially Speaking